Home › Education & learning › Make a grading rubric: how to do it with AI
Make a grading rubric: how to do it with AI
From official vendor pages; selected tasks also include dated logged-out free-plan trials. Report an error.
Beginner Risk: Low 🎓 Education & learning
Build an analytic grading rubric from your assignment and learning goals: criteria, 3 or 4 performance levels and a clear descriptor in each cell. AI is good at a first draft and at making descriptors parallel; you check that it matches your curriculum and test it on real student work.
Who it’s for: Teachers, instructors, trainers and anyone who has to grade work consistently.
Why low risk: A rubric draft contains no student data, but a vague or misaligned rubric leads to unfair grading.
ChatGPT has the highest score on our published rubric (94/100) of the 4 tools listed for this task. The free plan covers everyday text chats with limited uploads; Plus adds projects, scheduled tasks and custom GPTs (chatgpt.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026). OpenAI's pricing page lists ChatGPT for Teachers, a free plan for verified U.S. K–12 educators through June 2027 (chatgpt.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026).
Step by step
- Paste the assignment instructions and the curriculum expectations or learning goals it assesses.
- Say how many criteria and levels you want (for example 4 criteria × 4 levels) and the level labels your school uses.
- Ask for observable descriptors: what a marker would actually see in the work at each level.
- Ask for a student-friendly version in 'I can' language if you'll share it with the class.
- Test the rubric on 2 or 3 real pieces of work (without names) and fix any cell that's hard to apply.
- Save the final version as a template or reusable prompt for the next assignment.
AI prompts to make a grading rubric
Replace the [brackets] with your details. See all prompt examples
Create an analytic rubric as a table for this assignment. Criteria: [list, or 'suggest 4 based on the goals']. Levels: [Level 1–4 / Beginning–Exceeding]. Each cell should describe observable evidence in the work, not effort. Keep the language parallel across levels. Assignment: [paste] Learning goals: [paste]
Rewrite this rubric in 'I can' statements that a [grade] student can understand, keeping the same criteria and levels: [paste rubric]
Here is my rubric. Point out any cells that overlap, use vague words (like 'good' or 'some'), or would be hard to tell apart when marking, and suggest clearer wording: [paste]
Turn this rubric into a single-point rubric: one column with the 'meets expectations' description per criterion, plus blank 'Strengths' and 'Next steps' columns: [paste]
Illustrative example
You paste
Grade 7 persuasive essay; goals: clear claim, evidence, counter-argument, conventions; 4 levels.
A good answer looks like
Criterion 'Evidence' – Level 4: uses 3+ relevant, accurate pieces of evidence and explains how each supports the claim. Level 3: uses 2 relevant pieces with some explanation. Level 2: evidence is present but loosely connected. Level 1: little or no evidence.
Illustrative example written for this guide, not output captured from a specific tool.
Which tool to pick, and why
- ChatGPT (incl. Work & Codex): The free plan covers everyday text chats with limited uploads; Plus adds projects, scheduled tasks and custom GPTs (chatgpt.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026). OpenAI's pricing page lists ChatGPT for Teachers, a free plan for verified U.S. K–12 educators through June 2027 (chatgpt.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026). Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
- Claude (incl. Claude Code): The free plan can create files and documents (Claude Docs) and keeps up to 5 projects; Pro is US$20/month, or US$17/month billed annually (claude.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026). Free also lets you create files, so you can ask for the rubric as a document. Visit official website ↗
- Google Gemini: The free plan includes Canvas for editing a document alongside the chat, plus Gems for saving reusable instructions (gemini.google/subscriptions, checked Oct 23, 2026). Visit official website ↗
- Microsoft Copilot: Microsoft 365 Personal includes Copilot in the Word, Excel, PowerPoint and Outlook desktop apps (microsoft.com, checked Oct 23, 2026). Useful if you build rubrics in Word. Visit official website ↗
Reasons come from the capabilities, free-plan details and prices we've checked on official pages (separate from any dated trial above). Sources: chatgpt.com/pricing · claude.com/pricing · gemini.google/subscriptions/ · www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-copilot/for-individuals
Common mistakes
- Accepting criteria that don't match the learning goals you were given.
- Descriptors that measure effort or attitude instead of the work.
- Never testing the rubric on real samples before using it for marks.
Privacy tip
A rubric itself has no personal data. If you paste student samples to test it, remove names and identifying details first.
ChatGPT (incl. Work & Codex) setting · Claude (incl. Claude Code) setting · Google Gemini setting · Sources: help.openai.com/en/articles/7730893-data-controls-in-chatgpt · privacy.claude.com/en/articles/12109829-how-do-i-change-my-model-improvement-privacy-settings · support.google.com/gemini/answer/13594961