Home › Education & learning › Write report card comments: how to do it with AI
Write report card comments: how to do it with AI
From official vendor pages; selected tasks also include dated logged-out free-plan trials. Report an error.
Beginner Risk: Medium 🎓 Education & learning
Use AI to turn your own marks, observations and evidence into clear report card comments, then edit every one. The AI drafts wording; you supply the facts about each student and stay responsible for the final comment, as school board guidance on AI and assessment requires.
Who it’s for: K–12 teachers writing term reports, and tutors writing progress notes.
Why medium risk: Comments are about children and go to families. Generic or wrong comments damage trust, and student data needs an approved tool.
ChatGPT has the highest score on our published rubric (94/100) of the 4 tools listed for this task. OpenAI's pricing page lists ChatGPT for Teachers, a free plan for verified U.S. K–12 educators through June 2027 (chatgpt.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026).
When it fits, and when it doesn’t
Good fit:
- Turning your own observations into well-phrased comments
- Varying wording across a class
- Checking tone and jargon
Not a good fit:
- Deciding marks or levels
- Comments on sensitive topics (behaviour plans, health, family situations)
- Any case where your school's policy forbids it
Step by step
- Check your school or board's AI guidance first: many only allow student information in approved tools.
- For each student, jot 3 to 5 facts you observed: a strength with an example, one area to work on, and a next step.
- Replace names with initials or 'Student A', and leave out marks, diagnoses, IEP details and family information.
- Give the AI your board's format (word count, structure, tone) and a sample comment you like.
- Generate drafts in small batches, then edit each one so it contains a specific example only you could know.
- Put names back in your school's reporting system, not in the chat, and reread the final comment before submitting.
AI prompts to write report card comments
Replace the [brackets] with your details. See all prompt examples
You are helping a grade [grade] teacher write report card comments for [subject]. Using ONLY my notes, write one comment of about [60] words: one strength with the example I give, one next step that is specific and doable, and an encouraging closing. Use 'Student A' instead of a name. Don't add achievements I didn't mention. Notes: [your notes]
Expand each line of shorthand into a [50–70]-word report card comment in a warm, professional tone for parents. Keep each student's facts separate and don't invent details. Format: Student label, then the comment. [Student A: strong mental math, rushes word problems, next: underline the question] [Student B: ...]
These comments sound too similar. Rewrite them so each has a different opening and sentence structure, keeping every fact and the word count the same: [paste comments]
Review these comments for jargon a parent might not understand, negative framing, and anything that sounds like a diagnosis or label. Suggest a fix for each issue: [paste]
Illustrative example
You paste
Student A, grade 4 math: solves 2-digit multiplication accurately; explains strategy to peers; rushes multi-step word problems; next step: underline what the question asks.
A good answer looks like
Student A multiplies 2-digit numbers accurately and often explains strategies to classmates, which helps the whole group. Next term, Student A will work on slowing down with multi-step word problems by underlining what each question asks before solving.
Illustrative example written for this guide, not output captured from a specific tool.
Safe practice
- Don't use AI to assign or justify marks, or to write comments about behaviour, health or family matters.
- If your board says AI-drafted comments are not allowed, write them yourself; the prompts above also work as a checklist without AI.
Which tool to pick, and why
- ChatGPT (incl. Work & Codex): OpenAI's pricing page lists ChatGPT for Teachers, a free plan for verified U.S. K–12 educators through June 2027 (chatgpt.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026). Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
- Google Gemini: The free plan includes Canvas for editing a document alongside the chat, plus Gems for saving reusable instructions (gemini.google/subscriptions, checked Oct 23, 2026). Many schools already use Google Workspace, so check whether your school account has Gemini approved. Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
- Microsoft Copilot: Microsoft 365 Personal includes Copilot in the Word, Excel, PowerPoint and Outlook desktop apps (microsoft.com, checked Oct 23, 2026). If your board uses Microsoft 365, ask whether Copilot with your work account is the approved option. Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
- Claude (incl. Claude Code): The free plan can create files and documents (Claude Docs) and keeps up to 5 projects; Pro is US$20/month, or US$17/month billed annually (claude.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026). Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
Reasons come from the capabilities, free-plan details and prices we've checked on official pages (separate from any dated trial above). Sources: chatgpt.com/pricing · gemini.google/subscriptions/ · www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-copilot/for-individuals · claude.com/pricing
Common mistakes
- Pasting full names, marks or IEP details into a personal account.
- Sending comments that could describe any child.
- Letting AI decide the grade or the judgement; it only phrases what you already decided.
- Copying the same structure for the whole class so comments read as generated.
Privacy tip
Student information is personal data. Use the tool your school or board has approved for staff, remove names and identifying details, and turn off model training on any personal account you use for drafting.
ChatGPT (incl. Work & Codex) setting · Google Gemini setting · Microsoft Copilot setting · Claude (incl. Claude Code) setting · Sources: help.openai.com/en/articles/7730893-data-controls-in-chatgpt · support.google.com/gemini/answer/13594961 · support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls · privacy.claude.com/en/articles/12109829-how-do-i-change-my-model-improvement-privacy-settings