Home › HR & recruiting › Write a performance review: how to do it with AI
Write a performance review: how to do it with AI
From official vendor pages; selected tasks also include dated logged-out free-plan trials. Report an error.
General information only, not HR advice. A qualified professional should make the final decision.
Before you paste anything, remove names, contact details, ID numbers and other personal details, or replace them with placeholders like [Client A].
Beginner Risk: Medium 🧑💼 HR & recruiting
Use AI to turn your notes, examples and goals into a clear performance review draft, then edit it and own the result. AI helps with structure and fair, specific wording; the rating, the evidence and the decision about pay or promotion are yours.
Who it’s for: Managers and team leads writing reviews, and employees writing self-assessments.
Why medium risk: Reviews affect pay and careers. Vague or biased wording, or an AI-invented detail, can be unfair and create legal risk.
ChatGPT has the highest score on our published rubric (94/100) of the 4 tools listed for this task. The free plan covers everyday text chats with limited uploads; Plus adds projects, scheduled tasks and custom GPTs (chatgpt.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026).
When it fits, and when it doesn’t
Good fit:
- Organising your evidence into a clear structure
- Neutral, specific wording
- Self-assessments and SMART goals
Not a good fit:
- Choosing ratings, raises or discipline
- Performance-improvement or termination documents without HR review
- Reviews involving medical leave, accommodation or complaints
Step by step
- Check your company's AI policy: many only allow employee information in approved work tools.
- Collect evidence from the whole period: goals, results with numbers, examples, feedback from others.
- Remove the employee's name and anything about health, leave or protected characteristics.
- Ask for a draft in your company's review format, using only your evidence.
- Edit so each point has a concrete example, and check for biased words (e.g. 'abrasive', 'emotional').
- Decide the rating yourself, and keep the final version only in your HR system.
AI prompts to write a performance review
Replace the [brackets] with your details. See all prompt examples
Draft a performance review for 'Employee A' ([role]) using only my notes. Sections: summary, strengths (with examples), areas to develop (with examples), goals for next period (specific and measurable). Neutral, specific language; no rating. If my notes don't support a point, leave it out. Notes: [paste]
Review this performance review for vague or potentially biased language (personality words, double standards, recency bias). Quote each issue and suggest evidence-based wording: [paste]
Help me write my self-assessment. My goals were: [goals]. What I did: [results with numbers]. Write it in first person, confident but factual, under 300 words.
Turn these development areas into 3 SMART goals for the next 6 months: [paste]
Illustrative example
You paste
Employee A, support lead: cut first-response time from 9h to 4h; trained 2 new hires; missed two report deadlines in Q3.
A good answer looks like
Strengths: Reduced average first-response time from 9 to 4 hours by reorganising the queue… Area to develop: Two Q3 reports were submitted after the deadline; goal: submit monthly reports by the 3rd business day, with a reminder 2 days before.
Illustrative example written for this guide, not output captured from a specific tool.
Safe practice
- Don't use AI to decide ratings, raises, discipline or termination; those decisions stay with people (see Final hiring decision for the same principle).
Which tool to pick, and why
- Microsoft Copilot: Microsoft 365 Personal includes Copilot in the Word, Excel, PowerPoint and Outlook desktop apps (microsoft.com, checked Oct 23, 2026). If your company uses Microsoft 365, the work version of Copilot is usually the tool HR approves. Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
- ChatGPT (incl. Work & Codex): The free plan covers everyday text chats with limited uploads; Plus adds projects, scheduled tasks and custom GPTs (chatgpt.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026). Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
- Claude (incl. Claude Code): The free plan can create files and documents (Claude Docs) and keeps up to 5 projects; Pro is US$20/month, or US$17/month billed annually (claude.com/pricing, checked Oct 23, 2026). Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
- Google Gemini: The free plan includes Canvas for editing a document alongside the chat, plus Gems for saving reusable instructions (gemini.google/subscriptions, checked Oct 23, 2026). Free plan can do this Visit official website ↗
Reasons come from the capabilities, free-plan details and prices we've checked on official pages (separate from any dated trial above). Sources: www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-copilot/for-individuals · chatgpt.com/pricing · claude.com/pricing · gemini.google/subscriptions/
Common mistakes
- Pasting the employee's name, health or leave details into a personal account.
- Letting AI choose the rating or suggest pay outcomes.
- Generic praise that could describe anyone.
Privacy tip
Performance information is confidential personal data. Use your organisation's approved tool, refer to 'Employee A', and keep the final review in your HR system rather than in chat history.
Microsoft Copilot setting · ChatGPT (incl. Work & Codex) setting · Claude (incl. Claude Code) setting · Sources: support.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/microsoft-copilot/privacy-controls · help.openai.com/en/articles/7730893-data-controls-in-chatgpt · privacy.claude.com/en/articles/12109829-how-do-i-change-my-model-improvement-privacy-settings
See also
- Write a workplace incident report: write a workplace incident report